Will bradhicks devote any blog inches to the Baptist megachurch shooting? The one where unarmed parishioners disarmed a gunman after he killed the pastor during a service?
Well, I was wondering if it would inspire musings on culture war, like the Unitarian church shooting. And I was wondering that as someone who attends a Unitarian church - would you be as eloquent about the bravery of the congregants who, unarmed, took down the gunman, etc.? Though I guess if nothing came out about the motives, etc., well, there you are.
There was a modest amount of snark in the question, but also genuine curiosity.
I'm a little uncomfortable with the question, because I don't see the two crimes as all that comparable. The guy in Tennessee's motive was to attack an entire religion and an entire political party. The guy in Illinois, we don't even know what his motive was, as frustrating as that is. For what it's worth, even the people in the church are not (thankfully) painting this as "oh, look, our denomination of Christianity is under attack!" Even they understand that. Which makes this an apples and oranges kind of thing. If the guy had left a note in his pickup truck or at home or whatever that said that this was his attempt to send a message to right-wing Christian fundamentalists that they're destroying the country and decent American liberals like him weren't going to let them get away with it, then they'd be parallel cases. If we ever do find out that this was the guy's motive, you can reasonably expect me to have something to say about the parallel with the Knoxville situation. But until/unless we ever find out a motive, I'm not going to speculate.
When I did get a chance to chat with that reporter, just to make sure, I rattled off the four or five most obvious motivations I could come up with as to why I guy would shoot up a church, just to make sure they'd checked them all. The shooter had never attended that church before. He did not live in the same town as the pastor while he was a child, so it wasn't pent-up rage over molestation. No relative of his lost a ton of money to or gave a ton of money to the church. He had no visible grudge against Christianity, and no visible politics of his own. Yeah, they checked all of that. We're left with: a mildly crazy guy living with chronic pain seems to have maybe decided to commit suicide-by-cop, and picked a popular church's pastor as the guy to kill in order to make the cops show up and kill him, for no reason we can determine. Unsatisfying at best, isn't it?
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-userinfo.gif){kind=small}
![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png){kind=small}
no subject
Date: 2009-03-24 10:33 am (UTC)There was a modest amount of snark in the question, but also genuine curiosity.
no subject
Date: 2009-03-24 06:56 pm (UTC)When I did get a chance to chat with that reporter, just to make sure, I rattled off the four or five most obvious motivations I could come up with as to why I guy would shoot up a church, just to make sure they'd checked them all. The shooter had never attended that church before. He did not live in the same town as the pastor while he was a child, so it wasn't pent-up rage over molestation. No relative of his lost a ton of money to or gave a ton of money to the church. He had no visible grudge against Christianity, and no visible politics of his own. Yeah, they checked all of that. We're left with: a mildly crazy guy living with chronic pain seems to have maybe decided to commit suicide-by-cop, and picked a popular church's pastor as the guy to kill in order to make the cops show up and kill him, for no reason we can determine. Unsatisfying at best, isn't it?